music help: what do u think of my playing - Help.com

you are on your way to being awesome, keep playing for pure self-amusement and you will fail to not succeed.

no offence, but i can tell without reading your whole post that you were just throwing random notes togeather =/
try learning how to read sheet music, they have videos to help you learn how to play. other than that you cannot call this music since you do not know what your doing

Anonymous wrote:
you are on your way to being awesome, keep playing for pure self-amusement and you will fail to not succeed.

they said to be honest, your sugar coating the truth, they do not know what they are doing and your giving false hope to someone who will just be laughed at for the rest of their lives for thinking that THIS was music, which it is not.

Just sounded like somebody practicing chords.

Thanks everybody for being honst
But i was know what im doing and i know it was not that much good
but I like the Tune and it mean very much to me .
what do u think in this other playing
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9CQuh…

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:
you are on your way to being awesome, keep playing for pure self-amusement and you will fail to not succeed.

they said to be honest, your sugar coating the truth, they do not know what they are doing and your giving false hope to someone who will just be laughed at for the rest of their lives for thinking that THIS was music, which it is not.

i dont think i am, if you want to be the best you model the best and you keep playing nothing can stop you if you dont stop but when people start off they want feedback and sometimes to much of the truth can make you lose track of the reasons you fell inlove with music, their will be plenty of people around to tell him/her where they are going wrong.

Honestly and to tell you the truth — because you asked for: It sounds awful! It’s more dilettantish than a instructed beginner would do. (I know what I’m speaking about, because I’m a, experienced piano player.)
It’s not for public performance at all.

You have to take piano lessons!

Those people who suggest you learn more are just trying to help. I know that criticism hurts, but it is also frustrating and painful to not be able to play what you really want to play. A lot of learning music is overcoming challenges to be able to express yourself more fully in more ways, then it’s more fulfilling for you, easier, and not as difficult or frustrating.

There are so many ways to learn. If you go to a music store, like a place that sells instruments and sheet music, you can browse through all the teaching books and see what’s out there. Also there are a lot of interesting programs on computers to help. Mostly you have to play with others, but I’ve learned instruments by myself and got even better on them than on instruments I played in band. But studying things that experts wrote about it can help, like at least music teaching books or music theory books.