SPOILERS Harry Potter.
What are your theories?
Mine is like this Dumbledor is alive and snape is good. They faked the death to trick Voldemort. Harry trains for battle. At the final battle voldemort tries to kill nevil and harry jumps in the way and HARRY dies then at that moment a scar that looks like a lightning bolt appears on nevils head.
Thats all I got but I was wondering what you all think.
This closed post was written 2 years, 4 months ago | V/U/S: 1,534, 281, 11 | Edit Post | Report Post
Reciprocity (0)
Since writing this post needana may have helped people, but has not within the last 4 days. needana is a verified member, has been around for 2 years, 5 months and has 23 posts and 258 replies to their name.
Post Tags (10)
Replies (281)
Where were you?
You can also watch events on Help.com as they happen
Did anyone read the 7th book I want to know what happens!
I’m trying not to have any thoughts about the plot! Can’t wait to get it tomorrow though!
The seventh one isn’t out yet! Its out 21st of july
I thought it already come out…
Nope, 21st…trust me, i’m an avid fan!
My dad wont let me read it cuz we’re reading it together…. :(
thats a bit naff! what do you mean by reading it together?
Mine keeps saying 37 years and 6 months after post!!
i know, so does mine! If i’ve suddenly turned 57, i look and feel good for my age!
like i read it to my dad and he reads it to me you know to build reading skills
what is everybodies fav. harry book?
my dads all about learning… :(
that sounds cool, just make sure you don’t read any news reports, someone is bound to put a story out about who dies! my fave is the first one, you can’t beat the excitement of getting to diagon alley! the sixth one was a bit dark for me.
the sixth one was a transition book it was good but i like the 3rd.
My dad was sapossed to read the 5th and 6th with me but i read them any wayz lol
the third was interesting, as she led you to believe sirius was someone out to hurt harry, then you found out the truth… I can’t wait for all the loose ends to be tied up in this final book!
yea this book is going to be sooooo good!
Has any one seen the 5th harry potter yet?
yes it is.. did anyone else get a tad bit upset when dumbledore died?
i havnt my dad keeps saying be patiend or we won’t see it!
no, i’m waiting to see that, but the films are nowhere near as good as the books.
kiwi yes and it was just ok.
green yes i was devistated
i’m 20 too…i actually cried down the phone to my mum when i found out…needless to say, she thought i was a nutjob! are you both american?
scrap that, just saw where you come from!
yes i am. i have done a lot of traveling however
my dad said we might go there next summer! :)
yes very much gonna make it 12hrs in december
I’m going to Costa Rica a day after Christmas
oooh, going all out! haha i’m going over to new york next february for my 21st, first time in USA! looking forward to it, but i;m guessing its going to be cold!
i’ve never been the new york before
yes it will be cold. You shouldn’t do your 21st in new york ive been there and its awesome but you should do it in vegas. I live here and there is no place like it.
but new york will be amazing to
do you not get tired of all the showbiz stuff and lights etc.?
Or in Utah we are know to have the best snow in the world for skiing/ snowboarding…
I live like half an hour from the ski resorts so we go all the time
her 21 birthday not utah its dry on sundays and stuff like that.
After a while you don’t even notice them unless u want to.
i have a friend who lives in las vegas, he loves it too. are you both male or female?
Is ur friend Adam Friedland?
its unusual for a bloke to be into harry potter…did you start reading it from a young age? when did you start reading the books kiwi?
no, he’s called Luke Jermay, he does magic shows and works with derren brown.
Who likes Pirates of the Caribbean?
I started at a relativly young age and I was forced to but now I am happy about it.
the ride or the 1st movie I like. The other two are a waste of time and space and all that is holy.
forced? u were threatened with what if you didnt? I love the first pirates film, the second one lost me completely and i havent bothered with the third
ok same with me about the pirates. My mother listend to it in the car when I would go to practice and I complained and she told me to shut up. After a while i feel in love with the books and all that but I was forced to listen to it.
the third is the most funny omg i cracked up so many times and i usually dont laugh out loud
audio book of harry potter in the car*
bet you’re glad you listened now! (*i got that)
what is your favorite movie?
gone in sixty seconds, without a doubt!
i’ve never seen that, but a friend of mine did and afterwards he was convinced he was supposed to be a gangster!
well i have to go so bye every body
where are you from green eyes?
essex in england, hence why i asked earlier about if you’d been to england!
yea i figured just wondering. Maybe you heard traveling and england is your fav place anyways has the book come out in england yet
I didnt mean for that to come accross as brash! sorry! no, its due out at midnight tomorrow, think i might actually be sad enough to go and get it at midnight too..
I loved the 5th book…I could really identify with some of the things Harry goes through in that one. My copy of the 7th book shipped today!
oh i am going at midnight and not sleeping till i finish it. I am so excited because unlike all the other books this one promises to have closer an ending and i cant wait
when does your copy come in?
last book i read in 22 hours…was knackered, but it was so worth it. I can’t believe this will be the last one now!
I am glad it has been great the whole world obsessing over the same book but im glad its over its been part of my life for tooooo long.
marconius whats your theory man?
i know what you mean, she created such a storm with her books, they will be some of the most famous books ever now, and she got so many children reading too!
she is the first author self made billonair and have you ever seen kids reading such thick intense books before. In America some private schools baned the books can you believe that?
My theory? I try not to come up with them, since I don’t want to raise any expectations or assumptions. That only can lead to disappointment.
i know, its ridiculous. its only because she takes the magic she writes about from true paganism, so a lot of parents won’t let them read the books! I think they are amazing books, they make you feel like you’re there.
I think my copy is going to arrive on the release date…so either tomorrow or the 21st.
it should be the 21st..i think its a worldwide release date, stops the story leaking
welll i just got into harry potter bc i went with my best friend to see it on her birthday and i fell in love with pro.snape…soo my theory would be that harry dies and professor snape lives ahahah lol yeap
I think that no real MAIN protagonist is going to die.
I believe that things will end good…
HOWEVER,
there will be a little comment made near the end that could lead to a 8th book.
( Just a feeling I get from her writing).
I’ve been to England for 3 days before, When I was 16! Me and my mom did a 3-4 day lay-over before going to see family in Belgium.
I think there will not be an eighth book but a new series with the same world and a new protagonist that we will like a lot less.
I’m sure she will write another book about that world, but I don’t think she needs to with the amount of money she made!!
she doesn’t need to financally but every writer NEEDS to write and no one will read any book bye her that doesn’t have to do with harry potter.
Whats everyones fav. movie if its different than your fav. book
*fav harry potter movie
the last one was my fave as the acting got better, but i’ve not seen the new one, so it could well change!
so far my favorat book is the 3rd one, and what do you mean its odd for guys to read harry potter?
green eyes you box? what is that like?
yeah i do, its good to get any stress and anger out! I love it.
wow, i would not guess that you box from looking at your avatar…
do you ever box men or just women?
this is like a chat room almost… a site called help.com where people come to hang out…. so weird….
i know, blonde hair and a penchant for pink can be deceiving… lol men and women, its a class and you get paired up with different people and use pads, a bag etc. Its hard work, but good.
thats really cool. Anyone else have a surprising hobby. (green eye’s any others?)
ive been helping people on this site for a year… does that count?
g2g, help you later…
green eye’s do you have a job?
i am into driving…so far i’ve driven a Aston Martin DB9, Ferrari 360, Porsche 997 and 996, Lotus Elise and Subaru Impreza…surprising enough?
Yeah, i’m a Pharmacy Technician..what about you?
Law Office clerk and runner/ paralegal. (I don’t have a title yet but I do a lot of s***)
Yes I can’t believe you drove all those cars. how did you get to drive them?
where did u go?
cool did u or the team u rooted for win?
the DB9 and Porsche 997 was a christmas present last year, and the others were a christmas present this year! I want to drive a Lamborghini next…
Law is cool, do you want to be a Lawyer or are you not sure yet? (what is softball?)
softball is a version of baseball with a big ball old men play it and women play it in school. Instead of baseball. It is a unique version of baseball with a few variations.
Want to be a lawyer but haven’t made up my mind fully. Do you own these cars or is the present driving them?
*it was a track day, i didn’t actually get the cars
kiwi ever driven a car?
i know, it was such a laugh! Ferrari is beautiful, the Aston is just superb!
I can’t even imagine what it must be like to drive a car like that. The power and the speed. The status and all the other things. how did you feel when you drove it?
i truly doubt dumbledore’s dead. i’m suspecting that Snape is really good and they faked the death to fool voldie. harry better not die, everything’s getting so dark and depressing already, it’s just like, great, now he’s dead. well THAT was pointless…
Slightly scared! The ferrari was the quickest, 140mph is what i took it up to before i had to brake and turn… its just amazing, your adrenaline rushes and you end up with a HUGE grin on your face!
what else gives you a huge grin?
Whats the point if Harry dies? I don’t know but if he does she will have one.
erm…a good joke ;)
I don’t think Harry will die, but if he does, it will be shocking! I think Hagrid might die though…just a feeling i’ve got
i am back as well. i had forgotten i needed to pick up my brother, he was mad…
the interesting thing is that she won’t have to kill him off to end the series.
i was just thinking about sir conan doyle who several times tried to kill off sherlock holmes because he wanted to write about other stuff, but the resulting public outcry forced him to continue it. jkrowling won’t have to kill harry because he’ll be leaving hogwarts, and that will have enough finality to prevent people from insisting she continue the story…
oh my G-d hagrid. I never thought about that he just might. She said in some interview that well she was writing the book two people that she had not planned on dieing died.
exactly, it’ll be like - Harry has to get on with his life now, and that chapter of his life is finished.
welcome back this fire.
great post iamozy
exactly, she said on the Jonathan Ross show (that was the interview she did about it) that she was howling after she wrote out one of the characters, and Hagrid is so loveable, it may well be him :(
sorry! just giving my thoughts about the possible story line…
Okay, well, J.K. said that Dumbledor is definatly dead, so he isn’t coming back.
i think you maybe right. he will probably die protecting harry.
JK also said this will be her last book and I promise that is not true.
jkrowling’s definitely got it made in the shade as an author, though, anything and everything she puts out after this will be immediately bought and enshrined by harry potter fans… that must be nice :)
usually things turn out well in her earlier books. she has veered from that in the later ones, but i believe she will stay true to a pleasant ending, even if a few characters are lost, but i think this is just what i want to happen, and not what i think will happen.
Pittsburgh, PA, US | 2 years, 4 months ago (2 hours, 17 minutes after post)
Needana, how can you honstly promsie me that tis is not her last book?
and some statements that she made recently that has moved from definite statements to ambiguity.
Pittsburgh, PA, US | 2 years, 4 months ago (2 hours, 19 minutes after post)
Your not J.K. and your gut is just your gut, that has nothing to do with her not writing any more books. Sure she may right more if she gets bored, but for now she is saying that she is done
The fifth movie was okay, but it seemed to be rushed. They cover the first 15 chapters in about 15 minutes. I thought it was pretty cool though, I went and saw it in IMAX 3D. I thought that the whole movie would be in 3D, but it turns out only the last 20 minutes are 3D:-(
But they Picked an Awesome 20 Minutes to make 3D!!!
wait, are you saying that you don’t think this will be her last harry potter book? or did jkrowling say she wasn’t writing any more books at all?
i hope that she does write more in the magic world. i just want her to put some finality to this story so she doesn’t end up dieng before the series is complete… and it probably wont be as good later….
that is so true, her first books were almost cuddly by comparison to her last ones… she has got to write to a growing audience now, as adults wouldn’t be interested in cute little kid stories where no-one got hurt.
She said she may well write some more, and never say never, so it is very likely that she will, but not for another 10 years or so, as she has been working on harry potter for the last 17 years!
*i am getting that from the official interview she did, i’m not just guessing by the way
I do not think this is her last harry potter book
Pittsburgh, PA, US | 2 years, 4 months ago (2 hours, 21 minutes after post)
A good site to check on all harry potter things is www.mugglenet.com if anyone is intrested.
well, after 17 years, i would probably get sick of any character, no matter how cool it is. no wonder why she’s killing them all off..
lol
yea she is sick of it.
do you think anyone will read her books if they are about something else entirely now that she is ‘finished’?
yeah, like i said earlier “jkrowlingās definitely got it made in the shade as an author, though, anything and everything she puts out after this will be immediately bought and enshrined by harry potter fans⦔
i think they will, as she has established herself as an excellent writer, the question is..will they have the same impact as Harry Potter has?
everyone’s obviously seen that she is a great writer who can really captivate an audience
Pittsburgh, PA, US | 2 years, 4 months ago (2 hours, 24 minutes after post)
Needana, she said its her last book… I don’t understand how you think she will make more. I think if anyone knows anything its her.
She may write other books, and I hope they are about someone from like Ravenclaw or Hufflepuff… We never see those houses. I just hope if she does write again, it will be about magic and stuff like that.
listen: in an interview recently she recanted the last book thing she says something like ‘I may at some point write another one.’
she could write a prequil…
i think she’d probably switch genres completely, try something new. as an author, it would an interesting challenge for her that she’d probably be willing to try after doing fantasy for so long
if you’ve been writing about that world for the last 17 years…would you really want to keep writing about it???
that would be awesome if she wrote a prequil
some authors write one series most of there lives.
Pittsburgh, PA, US | 2 years, 4 months ago (2 hours, 27 minutes after post)
That would, like about Lily or James. and How they grew up. I know Harry saw it in Snapes pensive, but I’ll like to know more about them.
like write about the rise of voldemort, harry’s parents in hogwarts, dumbledore becoming headmaster, the ministry of magic, stuff like that?
for them its like a masterpiece they keep building. i try to connect the books i write with each other distantly, but i dont think she is the type to keep writing in the same series. she will try something new, if anything.
she touches on that stuff in her books though,how could she make it more interesting?
what if she gets the Seinfeld curse where the world wont take anything else from her but harry potter.
who knows what would make the best story, but a prequil would definetely be loved by all fans, no matter how bad it turned out.
Pittsburgh, PA, US | 2 years, 4 months ago (2 hours, 31 minutes after post)
Me too, I’m pumped!
140 something replies… i wonder if that is a record….
Pittsburgh, PA, US | 2 years, 4 months ago (2 hours, 32 minutes after post)
One day, 7 hours and 58 minutes until it comes out!!
heehee..not all of them have been about harry potter though, have they needana?
this thread will probably get deleted, since it will take up too much room and probably slow the website down…
they should institute a chat section
at the top of the page it says “chat” and that’s for anyone to go to
unless you meant, harry potter only…
no they havent all been about harry ;-)
i could write a javascript and php disposable chat box for each page, a simple script to make them and they would delete themselves in a month… i should help develop the site…
if i knew what on earth that all meant, i’d be very impressed ;)
sorry, i am a computer science major and i forget that no one else knows what php and etc is. yes it does.
just a little bit slow, and irritable if you try and ‘post too quickly’
yea the post to quickly thing sux.
i think it’s to prevent stuff like this from happening, aka, people turning discussion boards into a chat room, but oh well
right i’m off now…was nice chatting to you all, and i’m sure we’ll have another chat about the book when we’ve all read it! (i’m aiming for 20 hours) Byeeee! :)
by green eyes
same here, i just realized i want to work on my own book im currently writing…
OMG! i cannot believe this is the most popular post!
why? its a post about the most popular thing ever in our generation and this all took place real early this morning. I did this while I was working to pass the time. Besides I couldn’t leave after I found out Green Eyes was my age.
i dunno im not making any sense rite now…im tired and depressed. its 12.49am here and ill probably b up till 4am
lol! i dunno whats gonna happen, i think both harry and voldemort will die
212… can’t wait to start reading it! whoop whoop
213 never was a big fan of the book but i do watch the movies. i just want to know what happens in this book without having to read it
214 that takes away the fun of it! i’m the opposite, i don’t like the films but love the books! is this a record for the number of replies?
An Undisclosed Location | 2 years, 4 months ago (1 day, 3 hours after post)
i like reading them so i can point out all the mistakes in the movies
216 i love to read books but i just got tired of harry after the thrid book i read some of the forth but just stopped in the middle of it
lol queen i like doing that with movies of the books i have read it is fun and can be disapointing at the same time
218 i sit there and do exactly the same thing…’they’ve missed out the bit where..’, ‘thats not what happens!’ and ‘in the book…’ are regular comments out of my mouth when i’m watching them!
An Undisclosed Location | 2 years, 4 months ago (1 day, 3 hours after post)
hehe, yeah, thats exactly what i do! my friends tell me to shut up all time
220 i don’t just do it in harry potter films either..its an annoying habit of mine to natter during a film if i feel the need to!
An Undisclosed Location | 2 years, 4 months ago (1 day, 3 hours after post)
lol, same here! i suddenly dont feel so alone
you’re never alone on here, thats what i like about this site! always someone you can talk to
An Undisclosed Location | 2 years, 4 months ago (1 day, 3 hours after post)
yeah, help.com is sooo addictive that way
Wahoo! Only 2.5 hours left!
Oh my god we got it!!!!!
Soo pretty…
ya my sisters are going to wait out side tonight for the book while i am going to be at home watching tv and sleeping!
last nite me and my friends went out to see swarms of witches and wizards all over the place and there was 1 really long queue with a couple of ppl with witchey hats on and a pathetic litl queue and a fish and chip van! not what i was expecting for the book that nobody will shut up about.
i’ve got the book! ii’m on chapter ten, but i keep being interrupted! grr
how many pages are there?ive got it but i havent even opened it.
its not as thick as the previous books, but i dont want to look at the back to find out as i might read something that will spoil it!
lol.i read the last sentence of nearly all the books i read!i know its really weird and stupid and it ruins the book for me but i am weird and stupid.
I finished it!!! everyone hurry up reading it!!
someone tell me enough to get me interested so i will have a good reason to drive down to barnes and noble… dont spoil it just yet though, wait till a few people have finished, then ill avoid this thread and spoil away…
green i looked on the web and it told me how it ended so now i don’t have to read it and looking forward to the movie when ever it will come out
it will make a brilliant movie…you should still read it as you find out the truth about everything
ok, so I read the book.
It was intense emotionally and she ties it all up pretty nicely. I am impressed! This is a fun book, the part where harry realizes he must die was probably her best writing. I have one question about it though how did Nevel get the sword at the end of the book?
The final battle was so cool. and she really kept me guessing all the way through the book. I wasn’t right about anything but I dont mind. Its over a part of my life that has been a national obsession for so long and now it is over. She had a prologue maybe a little thin but it at that point it could’ve been bat dung I wouldn’t care.
Snaps exit at the end was spectacular. This was such a great book. I think that the character she killed off that made her cry probably was fred but it sucked when dobby died too.
What does everyone think?
It was definately her best writing yet…one minute i was laughing, next next i’d be holding my hand to my mouth in shock! The truth about snape was unreal, i think that might have been the reason she was crying so much as she knew the truth about his intentions! When i was reading about his memories, i did shed a tear at the thought he was in love with lily all those years and truly did care about harry.
Dobby dying was awful, and when lupin and tonks died, i had tears in my eyes again! Fred dying was probably the worst, as he was such a loveable character. I agree that the walk to the woods when harry knew he had to die was very stirring, she came so far with her writing over the years!
Neville had the sword because voldemort put the sorting hat on his head, the same way harry did in the chamber of secrets, and he called the sword, as only a true gryffindor can do.
Thanks for explaining the sword.
I too got very emotional while reading the book. I think that the point that made her cry was when Fred died, i dont think she expected it too happen.
Good triumphed.
I think that Dumbeldoors remorse at the end in the purgatory was good. I don’t know why harry was so forgiving of him but harry’s got one of those unnaturally large hearts and that is why the whole world loves him.
My sympathy for snape was minute i think that he was an extremely complicated charecter and he was always and needlessly unkind far too often for harry to name his child after him but hey I guess i hold grudges against people and harry doesn’t. The prologue was odd but necessary.
I could be a wonderful film though I wouldn’t put any money on it.
Will daniel radcliff be in the last two movies?
i think he will be, i’ve not heard any different, and he has took on the character now, i dont think they would try and replace.
i heard a rumor just wondering. Hows ur day going anything exciting happen besides reading the book?
i didn’t feel like reading the book so i went to wikipedia and read what they had there about it. i only read how it ended because that is all i was enterested in.
yea thats to bad the book was very powerful and fulfilling, everyman has his way so–ya know whatever.
ya but i can’t wait for the movie though!
yea it will be awesome i hope. :-)
me too! i am going to have my mom and sister tell me about the book when they read it
i’m so glad i didnt find out what happened without reading the book, but i finished it smiling so it was all good! Not been up to much really, had last three days off so just been chilling! what about u needana?
I too have been chilling, standard. I haven’t slept much. I read the new york times review that was supposed to be the big spoiler and it was to some extent. The book was great and I’ve not been up to much lately which is regrettable.
does the place u work at not mind u using the internet? what time is it there?
1:25. No im a receptionist mostly and so I am on the computer the whole time, they din’t care but someday they might.
i know its stupid but i still find that time difference strange! its 9.30pm over here! Did u think the book was going to be slightly thicker than it was?
yes I assumed it was going to be a dictionary. It was obvious that near the end she condensed a bit but I have no complaints.
it was nice and quick to read, it was strange how she started them off short then peaked with order of the phoenix, but i spose she had to release the right info at the right times. so…any british myths you have heard that i can dispell?
interesting question i know a few brits and i guess im wondering why the word C*** is so common. its not like that here, at least not with the same connotation.
lol it isnt that common! its a horrible word, derived from the word quaint which was used from centuries ago. its the worst word in our dialect. It may also have something to do with the fact it sounds more insulting when used in a british accent. Either way its a horrible word!
yes it is. LOL. ok other british myths… is it true that the food is terrible there? the food i had was bad but it was from a pub so thats pretty standard.
no! our food is great!! lol what did you have? It depends where you go and what you like, but you can’t beat good pub food like sausage and mash, steak and ale pie, fish and chips…
i had fish and chips idk why i didnt like it it was a while ago i was on my way to israel and so i was distracted.
i lived there for a year so i was going there for the year.
thats cool. have you heard of take that?
its a band. have you heard of the song ‘back for good’?
what is it about the band that you like so much? Is there something in the music that makes your feel a certain way?
why won they let people post here anymore?
I loved the book. I loved it. It was amazing and it mad me cry. J.K is the best.
yea it was very good. I was impressed and that is saying something. only in the world of me ‘course
I wonder if there ever will be a book or series that is as widely loved as these books?
Going back a few years, i would have said Lord of The Rings was well loved, its certainly as famous. Harry Potter is slightly more modern though.
maybe, do you think it has to be fantasy?
there is something about fantasy books that capture people’s imaginations…i’m sure there will be another series in a few years time that will be popular, but Harry Potter will be the most famous series for many many years to come!
I think that our next craze might be over a mystery writer. Since Sir Arthur Conan Doyle we haven’t had a super popular mystery series probably because they are all so similar but it would definitely have the suspence that is needed for a national craze. What other genres do you think will break into the void left by the harry potter saga’s exit from society?
I read somewhere that jk is going to write an encyclopedia about all the characters. that might be cool.
I’m not really sure, Harry Potter was only so good because children read it and parents started to get interested when they read it to their kids! Getting a genre for children would be the best way to start a craze, going for the 10+ age group.
That would be interesting! Do you think she will go back to the Harry Potter books? I don’t think they will be as popular if she does.
no they wont be as popular, an adult series about everyone all grown up fighting Malfoy might be cool but like I said she came put in an interview saying she is going to write another book about harry potter in encyclopedia style. she says that a lot of the characters had great back stories that she had to leave out because they were to germane.
do you think that radcliffe will be in the last movie even if he is like 20 or something?
Yeah, I think he will. I mean, geeze, he’s making so much money and I think he really likes it. I can’t see anyone else as being harry potter!
needana closed this post.
This post has been closed, no more replies. Thanks!
Invite Others to Help
Seeing as this post is closed, no invites are allowed.
